• Home
  • /
  • GAA
  • /
  • Croke Park Responds To Referee Criticism After Weekend's Hurling Semi-Finals

Croke Park Responds To Referee Criticism After Weekend's Hurling Semi-Finals

Croke Park Responds To Referee Criticism After Weekend's Hurling Semi-Finals
Maurice Brosnan
By Maurice Brosnan
Share this article

A large portion of the post-match discussion after both of the All-Ireland hurling semi-finals focused on the performance of the matchday referees.

On Saturday, Alan Kelly was the referee for Limerick and Kilkenny's blockbuster tie in a game that saw a penalty as well as debate around steps in the build-up to a goal and a deflected sideline that did not result in a '65.

gaa referees

On Sunday, Seán Cleere refereed Tipperary versus Wexford at Croke Park and once again there was discussion and criticism surrounding ruled out goals, hawk-eye's intervention and possible penalties.

Speaking to RTE, GAA’s National Match Officials Manager, Donal Smyth pointed out that officials are like players and can make mistakes.

"A referee makes in the region of 90 to 100 decisions in a game so they are going to get some of them wrong – that’s human nature. Players (make) mistakes too," he said.

People talk about the work that players put in, but referees put in the same work too and the decision that a referee makes in the last minute has to be the same as the decision they make in the first.

Seán Cleere was going as hard as any of the players at the end of the game. Between them the two teams brought on nine substitutes and he was still getting up and down the field with them.


He went on to point out that referees are aware when things go wrong.

"Our referees train as hard and work as hard as anyone else and they feel as bad as any player when it goes wrong because this is a huge part of their lives."

Speaking after Sunday's game, Tipperary boss Liam Sheedy explained he was frustrated with some decisions but understood it was a difficult job.


"I know Sean very well. He is a very competent referee. The game was moving at such a pace, it is certainly not an easy job. My job is much easier. From our point of view, there were a few times you thought you might get the break."

It was an issue highlighted on the Sunday Game programme as well, where the pundits agreed a referee does not get enough help in the modern game.

SEE ALSO: Liam Sheedy Proud To Overcome Doubters, Questionable Decisions And Challenges



Join The Monday Club Have a tip or something brilliant you wanted to share on? We're looking for loyal Balls readers free-to-join members club where top tipsters can win prizes and Balls merchandise

Processing your request...

You are now subscribed!

Share this article

Copyright © 2024. All rights reserved. Developed by Square1 and powered by PublisherPlus.com