Carlow Player Slams "Lack Of Respect" Over Ruislip Officiating Farce

Carlow Player Slams "Lack Of Respect" Over Ruislip Officiating Farce

Carlow's Daniel St. Ledger has criticised the GAA over showing a "lack of respect" to Division Four as a result of the failure of the GAA to provide linesmen and umpires for London's clash with Carlow at Ruislip. It meant that the game featured linesmen and umpires drafted from GAA clubs in London.

London manager Ciaran Deely tweeted his irritation, with Carlow's Turlough O'Brien replying in agreement.


Speaking on our new The So-Called Weaker Podcast, which is covering the national leagues from the point of view of the counties who probably won't win the All-Ireland, St.Ledger described the officiating as a "slap in the face for Division Four".

The incident also gives him cause to doubt a future tiered football championship, which outgoing Director-General Paraic Duffy has called necessary for the game.

I don't know [why it happened], I've no idea. It was a real lack of respect. You had four umpires from clubs in London, and two linesmen from London, too. Now nothing happened, thankfully, but it's a real slap in the face for Division four.

When you hear calls for tiered championships, incidents like that would put you off it. God forbid, if there's a Tommy Murphy Cup again, how we would be treated.

I can see the merit in a completely tiered championship - like at club level, with senior, intermediate, and junior. But on the flip side of that, it could be completely forgotten.

At the end of the day, the media has a huge interest with the top four or five teams, and on Sunday night the [lower tier] results weren't even mentioned.

That's why you'll see so many pulls from Division Three and Four managers against a tiered championship. It's not because we want to be going out getting hammered by big teams, but it's because we don't want to be forgotten, and stay relevant.

That was the first time I've ever been put out by something like that. I found it astonishing that something like that could happen. if Dublin and Kildare played at the weekend, imagine if four Kildare officials came out to do that game? It just wouldn't happen. It's unheard of. I don't see how our game in London should be any different to any other game.

It's absolutely ridiculous.

You can listen to the interview in full on the podcast. Subscribe on iTunes or by searching ' Podcasts' wherever you consume your pods.

See Also: Why Media Moaning About Elitism In Gaelic Football Need To Take A Look At Themselves

Gavin Cooney
Article written by
Changed the spelling of his name upon pressure from Michael Owen.

You may also like

The Stats Showing How Galway Clung To Limerick's Coattails In The All-Ireland Final
Dublin's Second-String Team Is Absolutely Frightening
Hurling Is "On Its Knees" Across Much Of The Country. Here's What The GAA Are Doing About It