• Home
  • /
  • Rugby
  • /
  • Review Of November: We Pick Our Team Of The Autumn Internationals

Review Of November: We Pick Our Team Of The Autumn Internationals

Review Of November: We Pick Our Team Of The Autumn Internationals
By Maurice Brosnan
Share this article

Fade to green. The Autumn Internationals and 2018 belong to Ireland. It was an exceptional month of rugby, with several key takeaways: Ireland's dominance, New Zealand's mortality, South Africa and Wales' resurgence, Australia's decline.

On this week's episode of World in Union, the Balls.ie rugby show getting an outside perspective on sport across the world, we selected our final team of the Autumn Internationals. Each week, we assessed the performance of a player and then compared it to his competitors. Due to the nature of the Autumn Internationals and team's experimentation, certain players only got limited chances to perform and thus miss out.

Here is the final team.

1- Cian Healy, Ireland 

Played three games over the month, two starts and one appearance from the bench. A monster Greg Feek coached scrum showing against New Zealand in what was a cruel twist of faith for All Blacks scrum coach and rugby guru Mike Cron as he watched his former student turn master. Steven Kitshoff was Healy's nearest competition.

2- Guilhem Guirado, France

Narrowly beat off competition from Codie Taylor for top spot but the Frenchman's incredible finishing ensures his place. Two tries last week during a shock defeat against Fiji, just a week after a sensational performance against Argentina that saw him finish with three defenders beaten, two clean breaks, two offloads and one try. His line-out was also 90%.

3- Tadhg Furlong, Ireland 

The best tighthead in the world bar none. Two exceptional performances against New Zealand and Argentina. Kyle Sinckler was in fine form for England with his impact in the loose a real asset, but he struggled massively against Karl Tu'inukuafe who Furlong crushed just a week later.

4- Leone Nakarawa, Fiji  

A historic November for Fiji as they stormed to an unprecedented high of eighth in the world rankings. The Racing lock has a stunning offloading ability and scored a vital try against France but it was his performance in adversity that really demonstrates his prowess. Scotland ran in 54 points against Fiji, yet Nakarawa refused to wilt and was a trojan tackler and breakdown operator. Devin Toner unlucky to miss out.


5- James Ryan, Ireland  

He conceded one silly penalty against Argentina, yet other than that it is near impossible to identify one other mistake he made this month. The best second row in the world this year.

6- Peter O'Mahony, Ireland 

His showing against New Zealand has attracted the plaudits it deserves. O'Mahony's rugby intelligence is unmatched and it is not just the breakdown where he proves his worth. A massive line-out operator and mobile around the park.

7- Justin Tipuric, Wales


The most competitive position of them all. Michael Leitch gave an exhibition of back-row play against England in Twickenham and Josh van der Flier was superb against the All Blacks, but two Man of the Match awards, including against a David Pocock/Michael Hooper Australia, as well as his game against South Africa, see Ospreys man Tipuric at openside flanker.


8- Mark Wilson, England 

Until last week, David Pocock was the stand-out number eight. However, injury midway through Australia versus Wales meant he missed the game against England where Wilson capped a fine month filling in for Billy Vunipola. Eddie Jones has the option of moving him to six for the Six Nations.

9- Baptiste Serin, France 

Ben Youngs unlucky to miss out, but overall the level of competition for this position was weak. Ireland experimented throughout, Gareth Davies did not have the best afternoon against South Africa, Aaron Smith's poor form continued until he was dropped after the Ireland game, Australia's Will Genia fumbled the ball twice against England and was dreadfully exposed when trying to cover across for Elliot Daly's try last week.

10- Handrè Pollard, South Africa 

The stand-out option. Johnny Sexton played two of four games for Ireland and one of those was a poor showing against Argentina. Owen Farrell was shoehorned in at centre to facilitate two first receivers and Beauden Barrett showed signs of fatigue. Pollard was outstanding against Scotland, creating the first try and scoring the second.


11- Jacob Stockdale, Ireland 


12- Bundee Aki, Ireland  

A great try against Argentina and magnificent performance against New Zealand.

13- Gary Ringrose, Ireland

Ringrose is quickly becoming the key man in this Andy Farrell defensive system. He has a remarkable ability to read the line and shoot up when necessary. Semi Radradra was brilliant against France and Jonathan Davies had two great games after returning from injury but Ringrose edges it.


14- Jonny May, England 

For all their trouble at full-back, England do have awesome depth at either wing. The 28-year-old is now in England's top ten try scorers after his effort against Australia last week.

15- Stuart Hogg, Scotland  

Just about beats Cheslin Kolbe to the full-back position. A terrific game against South Africa when his break down the wing almost resulted in a field-length try. Scotland scored off the resulting line-out anyway. He also set up Sean Maitland for the crucial score against Argentina last Saturday. Made 42 metres, with one clean break, two defenders beaten and one offload in that game.

Interestingly, only two Southern hemisphere players make it. However, this is more a reflection of the huge changes they made after each game rather than any massive weakness. For example, had New Zealand picked on form TJ Perenara would have started against Ireland and likely be in this team.


You can watch the full show here, or listen to it here and on all good podcast services.

SEE ALSO: 'Ireland Is The Bigger Game'- Is This Now The Greatest Rivalry In The Six Nations?

Join The Monday Club Have a tip or something brilliant you wanted to share on? We're looking for loyal Balls readers free-to-join members club where top tipsters can win prizes and Balls merchandise

Processing your request...

You are subscribed now!

Share this article

Copyright © 2023. All rights reserved. Developed by Square1 and powered by PublisherPlus.com