• Home
  • /
  • GAA
  • /
  • The Gaelic Football Rolling All-Stars: Round 5

The Gaelic Football Rolling All-Stars: Round 5

The Gaelic Football Rolling All-Stars: Round 5
By Maurice Brosnan Updated

It has been an unusual season for Gaelic football. The year has not been lacking in highly entertaining and competitive matches, but few of those have been televised and the overwhelming consensus is that the provincial systems are not fit for purpose.

Nevertheless, we are approaching the business end of the year and the rolling All-Stars are in need of updating. Only three players from the opening round remain in the team. The rolling All-Stars are a bid to ensure performances at this point of the year are not forgotten due to one-off performances in the latter stages.

After a weekend that saw 11 games, here is the fifth round of the rolling All-Stars.

1.Paddy Collum (out) –  Graham Brody (in)

No reflection on Collum who is a fine goalkeeper, but Brody is revolutionising the position single-handedly. We asked the question whether his approach would be shown up against Dublin and he once again was nominated as man of the match, following up on outstanding performances against Wexford and Carlow.

2. Eoghan Ban Gallagher (stays)

Donegal's best player in the Ulster final. A gem of a corner-back who epitomizes the modern need to be effective in both defence and attack.

3. Sean Andy O Ceallaigh (stays)

The Galway man has been excellent this year and holds onto the number 3 spot for another week at least.

4. Che Cullen (out) - Gareth Dillion (in)

A deserved return to the team for Dillion who has been Laois's best player this championship. Cullen had the unenviable task of man-marking Michael Murphy on Sunday and it proved difficult.


5. Diarmuid Masterson (out) – Paul Murphy (in)

For any smaller players or football coaches, Paul Murphy is a must-watch. In an era of unprecedented physicality, Murphy never steps moving and relies on technical brilliance to not only survive but thrive. Took his score well on Saturday evening.

6. Colm Begley (stays) 

Has had a superb year for Laois and was terrific in the first half. His ability to accurately kick pass off the outside of his left or right boot is phenomenal.

7. Sean Kelly (stays) 

There is a lesson in the wing-backs who have shone this year. Kelly, Murphy, Brian Howard and Jack McCaffrey -when he came on- are all pacey, mobile players who are nearly devastatingly effective going forward. This kind of player is crucial to the modern game.


8. Brian Fenton (stays) 

As highlighted by Tomás Ó Sé on the Sunday Game, Fenton made some uncharacteristic errors in the first half. However, the Raheny club man came into his own in the second half. He is just extraordinarily strong on the ball.

9. Sean Murphy (out) – David Moran (in) 

Tyrone have a devasting trio around the middle with Colm Cavanagh, Declan McClure and Mattie Donnelly which was always going to prove difficult for Murphy. Moran was utterly dominant in Páirc Uí Chaoimh and his passing ability is precisely what Kerry need to get their talented inside line on the ball.

10. Michael Murphy (stays) 

Michael Murphy has been captain for four Ulster Championships with this current Donegal team and looks as good as ever now that he has licence to roam as he pleases.


11. JJ Hutchinson (out) – Ciaran Kilkenny (in) 

1-4 for Kilkenny on Sunday. His ability to be effective from any spot on the pitch means opposition teams need to designate a man-marker to explicitly follow him.

12. Patrick McBrearty (stays)

Appears better suited to a forward system like this one. On Sunday every Donegal forward scored from play, removing the reliance that usually follows McBreaty.

13. Damien Comer (stays)

The Galway captain now knows he will lead his county out against Kerry in the first game of the Super 8s.


14. Jamie Brennan (stays)

Involved in a remarkable move that saw Brennan force a turnover on his own end line and corner-back Eoin Ban Gallagher land a score from it at the other end. A totally selfless inside forward who judges when to shoot and when to pass to perfection.

15. Luke Connolly (out) – Paul Geaney (in)

Six points for Geaney against Clare from play and 2-5 against Cork.

Luke Connolly was Cork's best player against Tipperary and one the best club footballers in the country last year, which is why it defies belief that he had to forage for ball out around the middle instead of getting good delivery inside. Took his score well and delivered some superb foot passes but the victim of a structure that did not get the most out of him.

Join The Monday Club Have a tip or something brilliant you wanted to share on? We're looking for loyal Balls readers free-to-join members club where top tipsters can win prizes and Balls merchandise

Processing your request...

You are subscribed now!

Copyright © 2022. All rights reserved. Developed by Square1 and powered by PublisherPlus.com